The Ultimate Buttermint Guide: Colors, Quantities & Event Planning Tips

Whether you just received your first order or you're planning a big event, this guide covers everything you need to know about buttermints - how many to order, which colors work for which occasions, how to display them beautifully, and how to get the most out of every bag.

Buttermints are one of the most versatile event candies available. Soft, creamy, melt-in-your-mouth texture. Individually wrapped for freshness and hygiene. Available in 30+ colors to match any theme, palette, or occasion. Whether you're a bride planning your dream reception, a mom organizing a baby shower, an office manager stocking the candy bowl, or an event planner juggling multiple clients - this guide is for you.

How Many Buttermints Do I Need?

This is the #1 question we get. Here is a simple breakdown by event type:

• Weddings: Plan for 3-4 mints per guest. A 150-person wedding needs 450-600 mints. That is 2-3 bags of 216ct.
• Baby Showers: Plan for 4-5 mints per guest. A 30-person shower needs 120-150 mints. One bag of 216ct covers it with extras for the candy dish.
• Corporate Events: Plan for 3-4 mints per person. A 50-person office event needs 150-200 mints. One 216ct bag is perfect.
• Office Candy Bowls: A standard desk bowl holds about 40-50 mints and gets refilled every 3-5 days depending on foot traffic. One 110ct bag lasts about 2-3 refills.
• Gift Bags: Add 5-8 mints per bag for a generous feel. A bag of 110ct fills about 15-20 gift bags.
• Party Favor Bags: 3-5 mints per bag is standard. One 216ct bag fills 45-70 favor bags.

Which Color Buttermint Should I Choose?

Matching your mint color to your event theme makes a huge difference in presentation. Here is a complete color guide by occasion:

Weddings

• Classic White Wedding: White or Ivory mints
• Black Tie Formal: Black and White or Black and Gold
• Rustic/Boho: Gold, Champagne, or Sage Green
• Beach/Coastal: Teal, Light Blue, or Coral
• Garden Party: Lavender, Blush Pink, or Mint Green
• Glamour/Gatsby: Black and Gold or Gold and White
• Modern Minimalist: White, Silver, or Black

Baby Showers

• Baby Boy: Light Blue, Navy, or Blue and White
• Baby Girl: Pink, Blush, or Pink and White
• Gender Neutral: Yellow/Gold, Lavender, or Mint Green
• Gender Reveal: Pink and Blue mix
• Jungle/Safari Theme: Lime Green or Orange
• Elephant Theme: Grey and White or Lavender

Graduations

• Any School: Match your school colors exactly
• Classic Graduation: Black and Gold or Black and White
• Medical/Nursing: Navy and White or Royal Blue
• Law School: Navy and Gold

Holidays & Seasonal

• Valentine's Day: Red, Pink, Hot Pink, or Red and White
• St. Patrick's Day: Lime Green or Green and White
• Easter: Pastel Pink, Lavender, Light Blue, or Yellow
• Halloween: Orange and Black or Orange
• Christmas: Red and White or Red and Green
• New Year's Eve: Black and Gold or Silver and White

Corporate & Professional

• Thank You Gifts: Gold Thank You wrapper or Silver
• Client Appreciation: Navy, Black, or Gold
• Real Estate Closings: White and Gold or Champagne
• Healthcare/Medical: Light Blue or White
• Law Firms: Navy and Gold or Black and Gold

How to Set Up a Buttermint Candy Buffet

A well-styled candy buffet elevates any event from ordinary to unforgettable. Here is how to do it right.

Choose Your Vessels

Glass apothecary jars are the gold standard for candy buffets. Use a mix of tall and short jars for visual interest. Fill large jars with your main mint color and smaller jars with accent colors. Mason jars work great for rustic or boho themes. Silver or gold trays add elegance for formal events. Small bowls and dishes work perfectly for intimate gatherings.

Styling Tips

Stick to 2-3 colors maximum for a clean, intentional look. Odd numbers of jars always look better than even numbers. Vary the height of your display using risers, books, or cake stands underneath tablecloths. Add a small handwritten label or chalkboard sign identifying the flavor. Place your largest jar or centerpiece in the middle and flank with smaller vessels. Always have a scoop or tongs available for guests.

How Much to Fill Your Jars

A standard apothecary jar holds approximately 100-150 mints. A small mason jar holds about 40-60 mints. Fill jars about three quarters full so they look abundant but not overflowing. Always keep a backup bag nearby to refill during the event.

Presentation Pro Tips

Add a small printed sign that says the flavor so guests know what they are grabbing. Coordinate your tablecloth color with your mint colors. Use a mirror or marble tile as your table base for an upscale look. Scatter a few loose mints around the base of jars for a full abundant look. Add greenery, flowers, or ribbon accents that match your event theme.

Buttermint Storage & Shelf Life

Nobody wants stale mints at their event. Here is everything you need to know about keeping your buttermints fresh.

Shelf Life

Properly stored buttermints last 12-18 months from the manufacture date. Individual wrapping is your best friend - each mint is sealed separately so one opened mint never affects the rest of the bag. You will find the best by date printed on the back of every bag.

Ideal Storage Conditions

Store in a cool dry place away from direct sunlight. Room temperature between 65-75 degrees Fahrenheit is ideal. Never store near a stove, oven, heating vent, or window with direct sun. Avoid humid areas like basements or near dishwashers. A pantry, closet shelf, or office cabinet works perfectly.

What to Avoid

Heat is the enemy of buttermints. Temperatures above 80 degrees will cause mints to soften and stick together inside their wrappers. Never leave bags in a hot car for extended periods. Avoid storing near strong odors as mints can absorb surrounding smells over time.

Buying in Bulk

If you are buying in bulk for multiple events throughout the year, buttermints store beautifully long term as long as conditions are right. Many event planners and office managers buy 6-12 bags at once to save on shipping and always have stock on hand. At 12-18 months shelf life you have plenty of time to work through a larger supply.

Event Day Tips

Pull mints from storage the day before your event to let them reach room temperature naturally. Never refrigerate buttermints as condensation will cause wrappers to stick. If mints feel slightly soft after storage in warm conditions, place the sealed bag in a cool room for a few hours before serving.

How to Use Buttermints in Gift Bags & Favor Bags

Buttermints are one of the most popular additions to gift bags and favor bags because they are individually wrapped, universally loved, and add an elegant touch without breaking the budget. Here is how to use them effectively.

How Many Per Bag

• 3 mints per bag - Minimal but sweet, great for large events on a budget
• 5 mints per bag - Standard, feels generous without overdoing it
• 8 mints per bag - Premium feel, great for weddings and corporate gifts
• 10+ mints per bag - Luxury presentation, ideal for VIP gifts and high end events

Best Bag Combinations

• Wedding favor bags: 5-8 white or gold mints plus a thank you card
• Baby shower bags: 5 pink or blue mints plus a small toy or candle
• Corporate gift boxes: 8-10 gold thank you mints plus branded items
• Teacher appreciation bags: 5 mints plus a small notepad or pen
• Real estate closing gifts: 8 mints in a thank you wrapper inside a gift basket
• Holiday office gifts: 10 mints in a seasonal wrapper plus hot cocoa packet

Presentation Tips

Place mints in a small clear cellophane bag tied with a ribbon inside the larger favor bag for an upscale look. Match ribbon color to your mint color. Use a small tag that says the flavor or a thank you message. For weddings, monogrammed stickers on a small cellophane bag of mints makes an elegant standalone favor that guests actually keep.

Corporate Gifting Ideas

Stock your reception desk with a glass bowl of gold Thank You mints for visitors. Add 5-8 mints to every client thank you package you send. Include a small bag in new client welcome kits. Send a 110ct bag as a standalone thank you gift to top clients - it is thoughtful, affordable, and memorable. Real estate agents love including mints in closing gift baskets with a note that says "sweet beginnings in your new home."

Frequently Asked Questions

Are buttermints the same as dinner mints?

Yes. Buttermints, butter mints, dinner mints, and melt away mints all refer to the same candy. Soft, creamy, individually wrapped pillow shaped mints with a smooth butter flavor. You have seen them in restaurants, hotels, and wedding receptions your whole life.

What do buttermints taste like?

Buttermints have a mild, creamy butter flavor with a light mint finish. They are not aggressively minty like a peppermint. The texture is soft and melt-in-your-mouth, not hard like a starlight mint. Most people describe them as smooth, sweet, and subtly refreshing.

Are buttermints kosher?

Yes. Tree Treasures buttermints are kosher certified. Check the product listing for the specific kosher certification details.

Are buttermints gluten free?

Yes. Buttermints do not contain gluten ingredients. Always check the label if you have severe allergies as manufacturing facilities may vary.

Do the colors affect the flavor?

No. All buttermint colors share the same classic butter mint flavor regardless of wrapper color. The color is only on the wrapper, not the candy itself.

Can I mix colors in one order?

Yes. Simply order multiple bags in different colors. Many customers order 2-3 colors to create a layered candy buffet look or to match a multi-color event theme.

How far in advance can I order for my event?

We recommend ordering 2-3 weeks before your event to allow for shipping and any unexpected delays. Since buttermints have a 12-18 month shelf life you can safely order months in advance if you find a great deal or want to guarantee stock.

Do you offer custom wrappers?

Custom wrapper options are coming soon. Sign up for our email list at mytreetreasures.com to be notified when custom options become available.

How do I store leftover mints after my event?

Store in a sealed bag or airtight container in a cool dry place. They will stay fresh for months. Great for refilling your office candy bowl or saving for your next event.

Where can I shop all colors and sizes?

Visit mytreetreasures.com/collections/the-buttermint-collection to see every color, size, and bundle available.

Shop the Buttermint Collection

Ready to order? Tree Treasures carries 30+ buttermint colors in 110 count and 216 count sizes. Whether you need a single bag for a small gathering or multiple colors for a large candy buffet, we have exactly what you need.

Shop the full collection at mytreetreasures.com

New colors are added regularly so bookmark this page and check back often. If you ever have questions about which color is right for your event, what quantity to order, or anything else buttermint related, reach out to us directly through the contact page at mytreetreasures.com.

Thank you for choosing Tree Treasures. We hope your event is everything you dreamed it would be.